Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

To select a good power tool, it is not enough just to study its technical characteristics, because even a powerful and multifunctional device in operation can show itself not at its best. This rating perforators for reliability, built on the basis of reviews "first hand" - those who have not the first day using these devices and knows even about minor flaws, or lack thereof.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

The best perforators for home

Since home perforators are purchased for periodic and often short-term work, the requirements for them are appropriate:

  • the device must be compact enough not to take up much space during storage;
  • power is sufficient even for short work on durable concrete;
  • reliability (the ability to periodically work in " for wear ") - you can not use the punch for several months, and then start a full repair;
  • availability of additional functions - mode switch, reverse, speed adjustment - all of them will come in handy anyway.

All devices that are included in the rating of perforators for the home, necessarily meet the listed requirements.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Bosch GBH 2-26 DFR Makita HR2470 AEG KH 24 XE
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Shank Type SDS-Plus SDS-Plus SDS-Plus
Number of modes 3 3 3
Impact force, J 2.7 2.7 2.3
Power consumption, W 800 780 720
Maximum drilling diameter in concrete, crown / drill, mm 68/26 54/24 50/24
Maximum drilling diameter in wood, mm 30 32 30
Maximum th drilling diameter in metal, mm 13 13 13
Reverse type by rotating the brushes by turning the brushes electronic
Safety clutch Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Speed ​​control Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Spindle speed, rev. / min 0 - 900 0 - 1100 0 - 1500
Frequency of beats per minute, beats. / min 0 - 4000 0 - 4500 0 - 4500
Drill chuck included Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Weight, kg 2.9 2.6 2.6

Bosch GBH 2-26 DFR

A device that the manufacturer itself positions as a model class "Professional", which shows its ability for long continuous work. Its 800-watt electric motor produces 900 revolutions per minute, with the possibility of electronic adjustment of their frequency, there is also a reverse function. In the punch mode, 4000 strikes are made to the working surface within a minute, but the device can also be used as a drill or screwdriver - an adapter for conventional drills is included. Drills with a diameter up to 26 mm are applied.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Bosch GBH 2 Pros -26 DFR

  1. Reliability. Without failures, it works even with constant non-compliance with the operating conditions - with frequent overheating.
  2. Versatility. Several modes of operation and a replaceable cartridge for drilling allow you to use it for any work.
  3. Durability. According to numerous reviews, users, even with intensive use, punch work for at least 3 to 6 years.
  4. Ease of use. Rubber linings and protective system absorb most vibrations.
  5. Additional Warranty. When registering on the website of the company Bosch, the warranty period is extended to 3 years

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Bosch GBH 2-26 DFR

  1. There is no ruler on the depth limiter.
  2. The drill chuck does not tolerate sticking of concrete dust — it is advisable to store it in appropriate conditions.
  3. Expensive to repair. If the puncher breaks and this is not a warranty case, the repair will not always be expedient.

Such a device will be a reliable assistant for frequent minor work. Suitable for domestic and professional use. The main thing is not to try to use it in cases where you need a very powerful punch. It will probably cope with such work, but it will greatly affect the overall service life of the device.

Makita HR2470

Universal three-mode punch for working on concrete bricks and similar materials.Ergonomic handle design for maximum vibration absorption. Equally, the device is convenient for use by left-handers and right-handers. Power of the electric motor is 780 Watts. Rotational speed of 1100 revolutions per minute - there is an adjustment of speed and reverse. In the slotting mode, 4500 strikes are made on the working surface.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Pros Makita HR2470

  1. Low level of vibration compared to competitors.
  2. It is unpretentious to the working conditions, in particular, it shows itself well when it is very dusty.
  3. Good cooling - when overheated, it cools down even without shutting down - at idle.
  4. A large number of consumables in free sale at relatively low prices.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Cons Makita HR2470

  1. B There is no cartridge for drilling at the factory, although the possibility of its installation is provided for by the design of the device.
  2. There are complaints about the backlash of the cartridge, which is why it is impossible to precisely drill a hole of small diameter or work with long drills - it is advisable to check this point when purchasing.
  3. In case of overheating, it may start to squeeze the grease out of the chuck mechanism.

The puncher is designed primarily for light work - it is in these conditions that it demonstrates all its positive aspects.

AEG KH 24 XE

A medium power multifunction punch - 720 watts with an SDS-Plus cartridge for drills up to 24 mm in diameter. The rotation speed of the electric motor is 1500 revolutions per minute with the possibility of adjustment and reverse stroke. The number of strokes on the working surface - 4500 / min.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Pros AEG KH 24 XE

  1. Extended warranty up to 3 years, subject to registration on the AEG website.
  2. Reliability - endures frequent overheating without consequences. With breaks it can be used even for demolition of not very thick partitions. There is a protection against jamming.
  3. Easy to understand - plus, if you have the skill of self-maintenance and minor repairs (wire replacement, etc.).
  4. Well thought-out ergonomics - the device is comfortable to hold.
  5. Light - weight is only 2.4 kg.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Cons AEG KH 24 XE

  1. Equipment - in the case there is only the punch itself and the warranty card.
  2. With a serious breakdown, the repair may not be much cheaper than buying a new punch.
  3. In some regions, the problem is to find an AEG service center - this point should be checked before purchasing.

If you don’t load the puncher with hard and extra-complicated works, then buying this device is one of the best solutions in terms of price-quality ratio for home use.

The best professional punchers

These devices are designed for those who make money on repairs and will load the puncher with daily long-term work - drilling holes in thick concrete, punching holes in walls, drilling crowns , shtabeniy grooves for electrical wiring, etc. The main criteria by which a professional punch is chosen: price, quality, rating - even the functionality is not in the first place. The main thing is to fulfill one’s immediate “duty”, but in any conditions.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Makita HR5001C Bosch GBH 8-45 DV DeWALT D25602K
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Shank Type SDS-Max SDS-Max SDS-Max
Number of Modes 2 2 2
Impact force, J 17.5 12.5 8
Power consumption, W 1500 1500 1250
Maximum drilling diameter with a crown in concrete, mm 160 125 100
Maximum drilling diameter with auger in concrete, mm 50 80 45
Reverse Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Vibration protection Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Safety clutch Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Speed ​​adjustment Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019 Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019
Spindle speed about. / min 120 - 240 0 - 305 210 - 415
The frequency of impacts, beats. / min 1100 - 2150 1380 - 2760 1430 - 2840
Weight, kg 10 8.9 6.9

Makita HR5001C

The powerful puncher with the electric motor of 1500 Watts allows use drills with a diameter of 50 mm and crowns up to 160 mm, giving a blow force up to 17.5 J. In operation, you can use 2 modes - chiselling and drilling with a blow. An electronic speed control system and a mechanical speed switch, plus a soft start system, are used. In terms of ergonomics, it is somewhat distinguished from competitors by a D-shaped handle, which is not a pin, but a closed handle.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Makita HR5001C Pros

  1. Design reliability. Users note that in a few years of work, in addition to replacing the engine brushes, there is no other damage.
  2. Accessories and spare parts are always in stock.
  3. Smooth start-up is a real help with a heavy tool.
  4. Long cable - 5 meters.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Makita HR5001C

  1. Great weight - with horizontal drilling, you have to hold 10 kg in your hands.
  2. Lack of vibroprotection.
  3. The operating mode switch protrudes from the case - it is easy to hook during operation.
  4. It may be too late to operate the clutch when the drill is jammed - if it is not good to hold the tool, it will jump out of hand. Need extra caution when working at height.

User feedback describes this punch as a professional and reliable tool. It must be remembered that the cost of devices of this class justifies the purchase only under the condition of permanent use - otherwise it is better to think about where it can be rented.

Bosch GBH 8-45 DV

Puncher with anti-vibration mechanism of double action - the vibrations are damped in the spring-loaded handle and the counterweight in the device case. An engine power of 1500 watts allows working with drills with a diameter of up to 80 mm and drilling holes with 125 mm crowns, delivering a impact force of up to 12.5 J. The rotary hammer drill has protection against jamming of the drill excluding the tool turning in hands.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Bosch GBH 8 Pros -45 DV

  1. The excellent work of the anti-vibration mechanism dampens most backward pulses for comfortable work.
  2. Six-speed adjustment of the engine speed allows you to select the optimum mode of operation.
  3. Well thought out ergonomics - all switches are located in easy to access places

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Cons Bosch GBH 8-45 DV

  1. Short power cord - 3 meters.
  2. There is no possibility to turn on the slotting mode without locking the start button, which is convenient when nibbling the drill.
  3. Some users note the location and shape of the extra handle that is inconvenient for them - if this is a critical moment, then it is better to evaluate how it lies in your hand when buying. In extreme cases, you can purchase a D-shaped.

Professional tool designed for comfortable and long-lasting work. The reliability of the device allows you to recoup the punch not only when working directly, but also renting it out.

DeWALT D25602K

A dual-mode rotary hammer drill with a 1250 watt engine for working with various building materials. Allows the use of drills and crowns with a diameter of 65 and 100 mm, respectively. The vibration protection mechanism and the relatively small weight of the device make it possible to use it longer without interruption for a “hand shift”, and a safety coupling with adjustable sensitivity makes the work safer.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Pros DeWALT D25602K

  1. Efficient ergonomics - except for the location of the switches, the design of the factory extra handle that can be rotated at 360 °.
  2. Dual anti-vibration protection - floating handle and compensator in the instrument case.
  3. Indicates the wear of the motor brushes and the need for maintenance.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Minuses DeWALT D25602K

  1. Small perforator weight and less than competitors engine power somewhat reduce the overall speed.
  2. Lack of reverse - if the drill is jammed, then you have to pull it out manually.
  3. A small number of service centers.

When choosing it is necessary to take into account that in comparison with competitors, there is some lack of power and impact force for working with very durable materials, but there is a tangible gain in convenience for the account of weight, when working with concrete of low and medium strength.

The best battery punchers

Requirements for such devices are not very different from those presented to network analogues, although the price difference is quite noticeable. The best perforator of this class is selected according to such indicators as the battery life, charging speed and availability of an additional battery, illumination of the working area. Separate attention should be paid to the last function, because the accumulator devices are primarily used in places without an electrical network.

Makita DHR242RFE

A three-mode rotary hammer drill that drills wood or metal and drills holes in concrete with a diameter of up to 24 mm, delivering a impact force of 2.4 J at a frequency of up to 4700 beats / min. The durability and simplicity of the device is ensured by the use of a brushless motor in the design with the ability to adjust the speed from 0 to 950 rpm.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Pros Makita DHR242RFE

  1. Compact and light. The weight of the punch is only 3.3 kg, which allows you to work with it even with one hand.
  2. The period of continuous operation is enough to fully charge the backup battery.
  3. High power allows you to work even with drills up to 1 m long.
  4. Finely drills small holes.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Cons Makita DHR242RFE

  1. No hooks for attachment to the mounting belt - if you need to temporarily release the punch from your hands, you have to look for where to put it - especially important when working at height.
  2. There is no interchangeable drill chuck included.
  3. An overly "soft" start button - it is easy to accidentally hook it and turn on the punch.

According to user feedback, there is no tangible difference between this device and network counterparts. The puncher is suitable for professional installers of low-current electrical circuits and similar work, when the mobility of the device becomes a decisive factor.

AEG BBH 18 Li-402C

Electric motor with 1,400 rpm, three modes of operation, impact force 2.3 J with frequency up to 4,200 per minute, drilling holes in concrete in diameter up to 24 mm, work with wood and metal with drills up to 30 and 13 mm with a chuck rotation frequency of up to 1,400 rpm - these characteristics are no different from network drills of this class. As a wireless punch, AEG is equipped with two batteries, the charging time of which is about 30 minutes, which allows you to work without interruption to recharge them.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

+ Pros AEG BBH 18 Li-402C

  1. Long battery life.
  2. Good balancing and vibration damping.
  3. Four-amp batteries with charge indicator.

Reliability Punchers Rating - Top 10 Top 2019

- Cons AEG BBH 18 Li-402C

  1. There is no belt or attachment to carry a punch on a construction site without holding it in hand.
  2. The depth gauge is made of plastic.
  3. When the air temperature is high, the sensor is activated, which considers that the perforator itself has overheated.
  4. There is no illumination of the working area - if you plan to work in low light conditions, then you also need a flashlight.

All other things being equal, this punch can be selected, if necessary, in an extended battery life, which is provided by high-capacity batteries.


Selection of goods carried out on the basis of reviews, opinions and opinions of users posted on various resources on the Internet. All information is taken from public sources. We do not cooperate with manufacturers and trademarks and do not call for the purchase of certain products. The article is informative.

Search

Related Articles